Coronavirus Latest News

The Guardian view on Boris Johnson’s race review: you cannot be serious

The government has dishonoured the public’s desire to have a proper conversation about the realities of race in today’s UK

Boris Johnson’s race review reported on Wednesday, although one might be forgiven for thinking that its conclusions were written out long ago. Setting up the commission last summer, the prime minister described its job as to “change the narrative so we stop the sense of victimisation and discrimination”. The head of his policy unit, Munira Mirza, has attacked what she calls “the anti-racism lobby and … its culture of grievance”. The personnel seem to have been appointed accordingly. Before one single scrap of evidence had been gathered, the verdict had been handed down. In the process, No 10 has not investigated the realities of racism but exploited them in an attempt to fuel a culture war. It has turned valid political concerns against the very people who voiced them.

If it is data on ethnic inequalities that Mr Johnson seeks, Whitehall has published report after report over the past few years proving “overt discrimination” in the criminal justice system (the Lammy review of 2017), “uncomfortable truths” about discrimination in schools, courts and workplaces (Theresa May’s race audit of 2017) , including over pay (the McGregor-Smith review of 2017); as well as “evidence” of racial disproportionality in deaths under police restraint (the Angiolini report, commissioned in 2015) and most recently the Windrush review of last March.

Some of the report’s statements are merely ignorant; others are downright offensive. It calls for “a dictionary or lexicon of well-known British words which are Indian in origin”, unaware that a famous glossary called Hobson-Jobson was published in 1903 and remains accessible today. The next sentence runs: “There is a new story about the Caribbean experience which speaks to the slave period not only being about profit and suffering but how culturally African people transformed themselves into a re-modelled African/Britain.” Historians record that more Africans were forcibly taken to Jamaica over the course of the slave trade than imported to the entire continent of North and Central America. Many were worked to death, suffering unimaginable violence and humiliation at the hands of their overseers. Far from being buried, this story demands to be told to British schoolchildren.

Continue reading…

Read the original article at The Guardian

Related Articles

Back to top button