UK coronavirus live: No 10 fails to apologise for Boris Johnson’s care home remarks; death toll rises by 155
Rishi Sunak preparing the for major economic update he will deliver in the Commons tomorrow covering coronavirus. Photograph: Simon Walker Hm Treasury/PA
That’s all from me. But the coverage continues on our global coronavirus live blog. It’s here.
Mel Stride, the Conservative chair of the Commons Treasury committee, has urged the government to abandon plans to treat coronavirus tests as a taxable benefit in kind. In a statement he said:
Many employees, especially healthcare and hospitality workers, are required to undergo regular coronavirus testing. This new guidance is unclear and will worry a large number of workers.
If these tests are to be treated as a taxable benefit in kind, the tax bill for workers could soon mount up.
Many of our key workers could be faced with the perverse incentive of avoiding employer-sponsored tests in order to reduce their tax bill.
This cannot be right. I’ve asked the chancellor to look into this as soon as possible.
Since the row about Boris Johnson’s comment about care homes is still rumbling on, here are two Twitter threads which are both worth reading.
From Tim Harford, presenter of BBC Radio 4’s More or Less
Tim Harford (@TimHarford)
Regarding the Prime Minister’s comments yesterday on care homes not following the advice given; last week’s episode of @BBCMoreOrLess is worth a listen: t.co/Iq8YJew5Aq
July 7, 2020
Tim Harford (@TimHarford)
The advice until 13th March was “Currently there is no evidence of transmission of COVID-19 in the United Kingdom. There is no need to do anything differently in any care setting at present.” (Section 18: t.co/MxrFsjknNz)
July 7, 2020
Tim Harford (@TimHarford)
After 13 March advice was that people shouldn’t visit care homes if they were unwell, and everyone should wash their hands. Meanwhile until about this time patients were being discharged from hospitals into care homes with no requirements for a covid-19 test.
July 7, 2020
Tim Harford (@TimHarford)
I have no special insight into whether care homes did anything wrong but it seems clear that merely following official guidance might not have protected anyone. The care home with which I have personal experience went further and sooner than official advice.
July 7, 2020
Tim Harford (@TimHarford)
Some people will reach the conclusion that the UK response was uniquely disastrous. If so, worth looking around. Many of our European neighbours, like us, sufferered a dreadful toll in care homes. This, too, is discussed in the programme.
July 7, 2020
From Anushka Asthana, presenter of the Guardian’s Today in Focus
Anushka Asthana (@AnushkaAsthana)
Wow the Boris Johnson comments on care homes really unbelievable. We’ve spoken to a few care providers for Today in Focus – and those that fared best were the ones that ignored govt’s lack of advice, and instead acted earlier themselves. t.co/Kuqj6IAdaZ
July 6, 2020
Anushka Asthana (@AnushkaAsthana)
We interviewed @Robert_Booth about his brilliant investigation into this – as well as to Sarah Harrison who brought in an early, total lockdown at Bridgedale House in Sheffield. Listen to this t.co/VsIElMveRW
July 6, 2020
Anushka Asthana (@AnushkaAsthana)
It wasn’t government advice that made them start acting to protect their residents in early March but because her finance director could see from what was happening in Spain and predicted the U.K. would be couple of weeks behind.
July 6, 2020
Anushka Asthana (@AnushkaAsthana)
And Anita Astell who runs Wren Hall initially took govt advice in good faith but was helped to bring in safer protocol by an expert who saw her being interviewed on media.
July 6, 2020
This is from Nicola Sturgeon, explaining why she did not answer a question about what would be in the SNP manifesto for next year’s Scottish parliamentary elections at her briefing today.
Nicola Sturgeon (@NicolaSturgeon)
To put this into context, I said I wouldn’t use my daily COVID updates – which are about communicating public health and other pandemic related info, not about politics – to talk about elections and manifestos, full stop. t.co/9c7kRu7zGj
July 7, 2020
A village library in an old phone box in Piddinghoe, East Sussex, padlocked due to the coronavirus pandemic. Photograph: Jon Santa Cruz/REX/Shutterstock
The Labour party announced in May that it would hold its party conference this autumn online. The Conservative party has now admitted that it will do more or less the same – although it is still hoping to hold “some aspects in the physical format”. This is from Amanda Milling, the party’s co-chairman.
Amanda Milling #StayAlert (@amandamilling)
This year @Conservatives will be holding a Virtual Conference – we’ll announce more details in due course.
If guidelines allow we hope we can include some elements of the traditional Party Conference we all know and love.
Peter, a pensioner, waiting this morning for Boots pharmacy to open in Newhaven Harbour, East Sussex, to get his prescription wearing a face mask and rubber gloves. Photograph: Jon Santa Cruz/Rex/Shutterstock
Independent Sage, the unofficial group set up by scientists who are shadowing Sage, the government’s Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies, has published a report (pdf) saying the government should be pursuing an “elimination strategy”. It says the current policy, involving the lockdown being eased gradually, will lead to “many thousands of deaths over the next nine months” because it implies an acceptable level of infection.
The group, which is chaired by Sir David King, a former chief scientific adviser to the government, says Boris Johnson should instead aim for a “zero Covid UK”.
This is what the report says about how this might be achieved. It says the government should:
Fully develop community-based and locally-led find, test, trace, isolate, support (FTTIS) programmes with expanded local laboratory provision, involvement of local public sector organisations and provision of all the resources necessary to enable adherence to the regulations on notification of infectious disease.
Restrict loosening of lockdown measures in any part of the UK until control of the outbreak has been achieved in that country.
Put in place well designed and scientifically based plans to act swiftly to contain and suppress completely and localise flare-ups in Covid-19 infections. Such plans to be exercised in simulation and well understood by the public before they have cause to be put into effect and implemented with full engagement with the communities affected.
Restrict incoming or outgoing personal travel internationally and within Britain and Ireland to the extent necessary to maintain control of the epidemic and, in particular to ensure effective isolation of incoming passengers.
Combine all these measures with a systematic public information campaign stressing that things are not ‘back to normal’ yet, that premature removal of restrictions in the midst of a deadly pandemic threatens to squander all the sacrifices of lockdown and that strict compliance with restrictions now will make a full return to normality come sooner. The public messaging must be done in a culturally acceptable manner to reach all communities especially those that have been disproportionately affected such as the deprived and ethnic minority populations.
King said:
While many other countries have adopted an approach of eradication we appear to be stumbling into another disastrous policy that accepts many thousands of people could die from Covid when they need not. We consider this grossly unethical.
The report argues that Scotland and Northern Ireland, as well as the Republic of Ireland, have coronavirus under control and are well placed to eliminate it. But England and Wales are not in the same position, it argues.
On that basis, it calls for travel between England and Scotland to be restricted.
It seems sensible that travel restrictions should either be instituted on public health grounds between England (and Wales) and Ireland and Scotland, or instituted if they are not already in operation. The Republic of Ireland has already instituted requirements arriving directly from Britain.
The Department of Health and Social Care has recorded a further 155 deaths in the UK in its latest daily update on coronavirus. That takes the official UK death total to 44,391.
As we try to point out every day, this official headline total used by the government is not the actual total. That is because these figures only include people who tested positive for coronavirus and died. Taking into account the deaths of people who did not have a test, but where coronavirus was cited on the death certificate, the real total is more than 55,000.
The Welsh health minister has expressed concern that workers at a food factory where there has been an outbreak of Covid-19 might be spreading the virus because they take it turns to use the same bed.
Speaking at the Welsh government’s daily briefing, Vaughan Gething said there had been a suggestion that workers were coming off shift and jumping into a bed just vacated by a housemate who then went off to work.
Gething made the remarks when he was asked about a Covid-19 outbreak associated with Rowan Foods in Wrexham, north Wales, where there have been 289 cases – an increase of six on last week. The minister said:
I’m genuinely concerned about the conditions that people live within, not just in houses of multiple occupation where people may share bathroom and toilet facilities or kitchens, and the opportunity for contact indoors and surfaces is an obvious concern. You’ve heard that from our scientists, and others.
But in particular, if there is reality to the suggestion that people are sharing beds, there’s an obvious risk if people finish one shift, then return from that shift to get into a bed that someone has just got out of. So there are real issues here about accommodation and how it may be an unhelpful factor in driving transmission within that workforce.